7 Signs That Your Water Heater Might Be Failing

Scott • February 16, 2022
Abstract waves of red and blue, possibly representing a data visualization.

Share this article

water heater repair & replacement

Your water heater is a plumbing fixture in your home that you probably don’t pay much attention to. Unlike your faucets or shower, which you turn on and off daily, your water heater works behind the scenes for you. If your water heater starts failing, you may not recognize some of the warning signs as quickly as you should.



Before you get left standing literally in the cold, freezing during your morning shower because your water heater isn’t working correctly, check out this list of 7 signs that your water heater might be failing you.

Not Enough Hot Water

Your water heater has two heating elements in the unit and heats multiple gallons of water at any time. A typical hot water heater can output 30-40 minutes of hot water before needing to refill and reheat.


If you find that you’re not getting near that amount of hot water from your water heater, it’s highly possible that one of your heating elements isn’t working correctly. Run a test and time the number of minutes it takes to run out of hot water. If it’s less than 30, contact the specialists at 1st American Plumbing, Heating & Air, and we’ll send someone out to inspect your water tank for you.

Inconsistent Water Temperature

Fluctuating water temperature is a good indication that something is going wrong with your water heater. This typically stems from the accumulation of mineral deposits over time. These mineral deposits cover the heating element, making heating the water more difficult than it should be.



If your unit is fairly new, the experts from 1st American Plumbing, Heating & Air can repair your water heater. But if it’s an older model, you’re most likely better off replacing your tank. Call our experts today if you need a recommendation of what to do.

Discolored Water Coming from Faucets

When the color of water coming from your faucets is anything but clear, it should be a cause for concern. Sedimentation in your hot water tank can cause your water to appear orange or brown, which could be a health hazard.



Contact a qualified plumber immediately and ask if they can come and examine your water heater. Your tank may need cleaning, or it may be time to replace your water heater.

Odd Noises Coming from the Heater

Small noises coming from your water heater can be perfectly normal. If you start to hear sounds like tapping or knocking coming from your water heater, it’s likely you have sediment buildup in the tank. This buildup can cause small tears and cracks in the metal tank, causing it to leak, which could cause damage to your home and end up being very costly.



If you’re concerned about the noises coming from your water heater, contact 1st American Plumbing, Heating & Air to evaluate your tank. It may only require a tank flush and a minor cleaning.

Water Leaking from the Tank

As we mentioned above, noise causes cracks and tears in your water heating tank. When these cracks and tears occur, water leaks from the tank. These leaks can be small, and often unnoticeable, but other times they can be large and flood your home quickly.


If you happen to notice a small leak, have it repaired quickly. Ignoring even the smallest amount of water pooling at the base of your water heater could mean a bigger problem is lurking.

Low Water Pressure

If the sediment and minerals are building up in your water heater, the inside of your water tank could be corroding. All of this corrosion eventually settles near the bottom of the tank, but sometimes the sediment can get pulled up into the water supply line and will cause a blockage. This blockage lowers the water pressure that’s being output.

Also, the older your water heater, the more likely it is that you will experience low water pressure.

Age of Water Heater

If your water heater is more than 10 years old and your water heater is showing any of these signs above, it’s probably time to replace it. Most water heaters last ten to fifteen years. If you’ve got a lot of people who use water in your home, that lifespan could be shorter.


If you’re experiencing at least one or more of these signs above, you should contact the experts at 1st American Plumbing, Heating & Air at (801) 477-5818 or by filling out this online form. Not only are our expert technicians the most trusted in the valley, but we will respond to you in a timely manner and get you on our schedule as soon as we can.

Recent Posts

Tankless Water Heater
By Gravitate One December 17, 2025
Read our blog post about Tankless Water Heaters: The Future of Efficient Water Heating for Your Home. 1st American Plumbing is expert in heating in the SLC valley.
furnace
By Gravitate One December 15, 2025
Need new furnace installation in Salt Lake or Utah County? 1st American Plumbing provides high-efficiency HVAC replacement. Get ready for winter with reliable heat.
broken sewer pipe
By Gravitate One December 5, 2025
Sewer line repair in Salt Lake, Davis, and Weber Counties. We offer expert diagnosis, hydro jetting, and trenchless pipe lining.
blue pipe
By Gravitate One December 2, 2025
Get water line repair in Salt Lake & Utah Counties. We diagnose leaks fast and offer trenchless solutions to protect your home.
Heater installation
By Gravitate One November 3, 2025
Heater installation in Northern Utah: we offer expert installation of furnaces, heat pumps & boilers for home comfort and energy efficiency.
boiler services
By Gravitate One October 30, 2025
Ensure your home's warmth with professional boiler services in Northern Utah. 1st American Plumbing offers maintenance, repair & installation
heater
By 1st American Plumbing, Heating & Air February 26, 2025
Midvale, UT, HVAC experts discuss common indications of a faulty heater needing repair.
dual port manometer and pressure switch tester
By Scott February 26, 2024
Cut utility costs with these easy tips: save on water, heating, and electricity while boosting energy efficiency. Start reducing your bills today!
frozen pipe
By Scott January 22, 2024
Prevent frozen pipes in Utah winter with 6 simple tips. Insulate, seal leaks, let faucets drip, and more to avoid costly repairs. Stay cozy and safe!
plumber at work
By Scott August 23, 2023
Uncover 7 common summer plumbing issues and expert solutions to keep your home running smoothly. From dripping faucets to sewer backups, we’ve got you covered!
Show More