6 Signs That It’s Time to Replace Your Toilet

Scott • March 15, 2022
Abstract waves of red and blue, possibly representing a data visualization.

Share this article

toilet repair replacement

Toilets are important fixtures in a home, and they’re used often by multiple members in a household. While we would all like it if toilets lasted forever and never needing replacing, that’s just not true. Toilets last an average of 10-15 years, and if you’re experiencing issues with your toilet, that could be sooner. So how do you know when it’s time to replace your toilet? We’ve gathered a list below detailing six important signs that it’s time to change out your old toilet for a new one.

Continual Clogging

Clogs in your toilet can be messy, frustrating and even stressful. While random clogs can happen on occasion, recurring clogs that happen regularly are a sure sign something bigger is going on. It could mean there’s something more than a small toy or too much toilet paper blocking the water, and it’s time to call in a professional.



Also, older low-flush toilets don’t move materials through the pipes easily so frequent stoppages are more common. Mineral deposits could also be building up, which slows water flow and draining. New models of toilets have been created with much better technology and water savings have been highly improved so flushing is more consistent and less troublesome.

No Longer Flushing

If your toilet doesn’t flush like it used to, there are a few things you should check out. First, check the handle to ensure it’s attached to the flapper. As you depress the handle, the chain lifts the flapper and water should rush through the bowl.


Check these items first. If you find that the internal parts are working correctly and your toilet still won’t flush, it could be time to replace your toilet. Remember that toilets aren’t meant to last forever.

Cracks and Leaks

Invisible hairline cracks, bad seals and small leaks in your toilet can often go unnoticed. But once water begins gathering around the base of the toilet, the flooring can soften and floor damage can happen.



Porcelain is a sturdy material, but it can still wear down. If you see even a small amount of water at the base of your toilet, check it out immediately. If the leak becomes constant, a new toilet should be in your future.

Old in Age

In 1992, the Environmental Protection Agency passed the Energy Policy Act that requires residential toilets use no more than 1.6 gallons of water for each flush. Today’s low flow toilets use approximately half of that amount.



If you’re environmentally conscious, replace your toilet to save on water usage. There are many homeowners that still have older models in their homes, and it’s wasteful plus costly. A new toilet can save 2 or more gallons per flush than an old one, so schedule to get a replacement soon.

Constant Running

When your toilet constantly runs, the common culprit is an old flapper or the float isn’t set correctly. It could also mean you have a water leak somewhere and the toilet needs to be checked more thoroughly.



When you’ve checked the flapper and float and still experience the running noise day and night, call our experts at 1st American Plumbing, Heating & Air as soon as you can. The constant running will be an expensive problem until you replace your toilet.

Wobbling

When a toilet wobbles as you sit on it, there could a few reasons behind the rocking. The first reason could be that the screws at the base of the bowl have become loose. Tightening the screws could fix the issue quickly.


A more serious reason toilets wobble is because of water damage that has occurred in the floor beneath the toilet. This causes screws to not hold the bowl tight to the floor. If you can’t determine the reason behind the wobble, you may need a new toilet.


Each person in a home uses the toilet 6-8 times per day. So you need your toilet to be dependable and working correctly. If your toilet requires a few repairs, that can be normal. But when those repairs occur more frequently, this could be a signal that you should call your local plumber. The expert technicians at 1st American Plumbing, Heating & Air will come to your home and investigate your toilet troubles.



Call us at (801) 477-5818 and schedule your service today.

Recent Posts

Tankless Water Heater
By Gravitate One December 17, 2025
Read our blog post about Tankless Water Heaters: The Future of Efficient Water Heating for Your Home. 1st American Plumbing is expert in heating in the SLC valley.
furnace
By Gravitate One December 15, 2025
Need new furnace installation in Salt Lake or Utah County? 1st American Plumbing provides high-efficiency HVAC replacement. Get ready for winter with reliable heat.
broken sewer pipe
By Gravitate One December 5, 2025
Sewer line repair in Salt Lake, Davis, and Weber Counties. We offer expert diagnosis, hydro jetting, and trenchless pipe lining.
blue pipe
By Gravitate One December 2, 2025
Get water line repair in Salt Lake & Utah Counties. We diagnose leaks fast and offer trenchless solutions to protect your home.
Heater installation
By Gravitate One November 3, 2025
Heater installation in Northern Utah: we offer expert installation of furnaces, heat pumps & boilers for home comfort and energy efficiency.
boiler services
By Gravitate One October 30, 2025
Ensure your home's warmth with professional boiler services in Northern Utah. 1st American Plumbing offers maintenance, repair & installation
heater
By 1st American Plumbing, Heating & Air February 26, 2025
Midvale, UT, HVAC experts discuss common indications of a faulty heater needing repair.
dual port manometer and pressure switch tester
By Scott February 26, 2024
Cut utility costs with these easy tips: save on water, heating, and electricity while boosting energy efficiency. Start reducing your bills today!
frozen pipe
By Scott January 22, 2024
Prevent frozen pipes in Utah winter with 6 simple tips. Insulate, seal leaks, let faucets drip, and more to avoid costly repairs. Stay cozy and safe!
plumber at work
By Scott August 23, 2023
Uncover 7 common summer plumbing issues and expert solutions to keep your home running smoothly. From dripping faucets to sewer backups, we’ve got you covered!
Show More